Evidence browser
Explore the evidence
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
36,013 claims
People living in the most deprived areas of England are more likely to be referred to IAPT services but less likely to recover by the end of treatment.
people living in the most deprived areas of England are more likely to be referred to IAPT services than those from the least deprived areas. However, the data also shows that people from the most deprived populations are less likely to use such services and less likely to have recovered by the end of treatment compared to those living in the least deprived areas
Service · Observational claim · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 64
The reforms aim to reduce the scope for biases in treatment choices and improve patient satisfaction among ethnic minorities.
Increased transparency and scrutiny of decisions will improve the patients right to challenge and should therefore result in less disparity of treatment across groups by reducing the scope for biases to contribute towards treatment choices
Policy · Policy statement · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 61
People from black ethnic backgrounds have higher rates of detention under the Mental Health Act compared to white British people.
Black or Black British standardised detention rates (343.5 per 100,000 population) were over four times higher than that of the White British group (74.7 per 100,000 population)
Service · Observational claim · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 60
The reforms are expected to increase demand for advocacy services, but not necessarily impose additional financial burdens on providers.
Participants suggested that, consistent with the analysis in this IA, the reforms will bring an increase in demand for advocacy services, but it was hard to predict the precise scale of this demand. However, changes in the MHA were not seen as providing additional burdens (in net financial terms) to the organisations.
Commissioning · Stakeholder position · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 59
The estimated net benefit of Option 2 is -£296 million over a 20-year period.
Over the 20 year time horizon, the estimated net benefit are estimated to be -£296 million in 2022/23 prices and in Present Value terms. This pertains to monetised benefits estimated at £771 million minus costs (excluding health opportunity costs) estimated at £1,067 million.
Financial · Funding statement · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 56
The preferred option is expected to modernize the MHA and improve patient choice and autonomy.
Overall, Option 2 is considered to be the preferred option as the implementation of the Government proposals is expected to modernise the MHA and make it fit for purpose. In particular, the proposals are expected to bring significant benefits to patients interacting with the MHA through increasing patient choice and autonomy over their treatment
Policy · Policy statement · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 56
The total additional discounted cost in the Justice system could range between £242 million less and £82 million more over the appraisal period.
In the Justice system, the total additional discounted cost could range between £242 million less to £82 million more over the appraisal period (£137 million as the central estimate).
Financial · Risk statement · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 54
The Justice system's costs are estimated to be £1 million over ten years in the central scenario.
Total 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 1
Financial · Funding statement · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 50
The central scenario estimates that the Health and Social Care system will cost £771 million over ten years.
Total 48 46 45 43 42 40 39 38 37 35 771
Financial · Funding statement · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 50
Improvements in mental health outcomes are expected to result in significant economic and social gains.
Under the proposed policy Option 2, it is also expected that there will be significant economic and social gains resulting from the improvements in health and wellbeing of patients detained under the MHA, largely through the improvements in human capital but also through wider impacts on the economy.
Financial · Policy statement · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 48
Advance decision-making can improve therapeutic relationships and reduce negative coercive treatment experiences.
They can also improve therapeutic relationships and trust in mental health professionals – there is evidence suggesting that ACDs may reduce negative coercive treatment experiences, which reduce willingness to interact with mental health services
Service · Observational claim · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 47
The proposed reforms may lead to fewer and shorter detentions under the Mental Health Act.
These changes are expected to result in fewer and shorter MHA detentions, all other things being equal, as a stronger and clearer detention criteria will mean that people are only detained when there is a clear justification for doing so and that they are discharged as soon as that justification ceases to be relevant.
Policy · Policy statement · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 47
Interventions involving crisis planning, such as ACDs, are expected to reduce compulsory admissions by 25%.
A recently published systematic review estimated the pooled benefit of five studies and found a 25% (range from 7% to 39%) reduction in compulsory admissions among those receiving crisis-planning interventions
Service · Observational claim · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 40
The estimated costs for the policy interventions over a 20-year period are £1,658 million in undiscounted terms.
Overall additional undiscounted costs for these three areas are estimated at £1,658 million for the 20-year period
Financial · Funding statement · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 37
The introduction of a 28-day statutory time limit for transfers from prisons and IRCs to mental health hospitals is expected to reduce delays.
Despite these potential costs and risks, we are confident that the introduction of a 28-day statutory time-limit is an effective means of tackling delays to transfers
Policy · Policy statement · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 36
Only 132 people were held in police stations under Section 136 across England and Wales in 2020/21.
only 132 people were held in stations under Section 136 across England and Wales in 2020/21
Operational · Observational claim · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 33
The proposals could result in an additional legal aid cost of £67 million over the appraisal period.
Over the 14-year appraisal period it is estimated that the proposals could result in an additional legal aid cost of £67 million.
Financial · Funding statement · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 32
The estimated additional cost for expanded Mental Health Tribunal powers is around £5 million.
This results in extra sitting days per year for the MHT therefore incurring extra costs, but it is estimated that these are minimal compared to the total additional costs for the Justice system. The estimated additional cost is therefore around £5 million.
Financial · Funding statement · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 31
The estimated additional costs for expanded powers of the Mental Health Tribunal over a 14-year period will amount to £6 million.
This will again result in an estimate of additional judicial time of one hour per case for an additional 851 receipts, resulting in 170 extra sitting days for the MHT per year, assuming there are 5 hours per sitting day. This corresponds to an additional cost estimated at around £6 million over the appraisal period.
Financial · Funding statement · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 31
The estimated additional costs for automatic referrals to the Mental Health Tribunal over a 14-year period will amount to £171 million.
Automatic referrals are the key cost driver of the MHA reforms on the Justice system with an estimated additional cost of £171m (undiscounted) over the 14-year appraisal period, as seen below in the table below.
Financial · Funding statement · From Draft Mental Health Bill 2022 — Draft Mental Health Bill: impact assessment, page 29