Evidence browser
Explore the evidence
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
36,013 claims
The government aims to reduce reliance on inpatient services for people with learning disabilities or autism by ensuring detention is only used when a co-occurring mental health condition is identified.
We propose that neither learning disability nor autism would be considered a mental disorder for which someone can be detained for treatment under Section 3 of the Act. People with a learning disability or autistic people could only be detained for treatment if a co-occurring mental health condition is identified by clinicians.
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act (web accessible), page 14
The government plans to develop a more diverse workforce and culturally appropriate advocates for better support of patients from all ethnic backgrounds.
We will also deliver on our commitment to improve how people with a learning disability and autistic people are treated in law, with a separate legal approach more suited to their needs. This acts on our manifesto pledge and on our commitment earlier last year to the Joint Committee on Human Rights (JCHR) that individuals within this group should only be in inpatient care for as short a time, as close to home and in the least restrictive setting possible, with a clear, therapeutic benefit, not as a
Commissioning · Commitment statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act (web accessible), page 7
The government aims to implement reforms that prioritize individual rights and proportionate intervention.
This Government believes firmly in increasing the liberty of its citizens. And so we will seek to implement reforms which see people not just as patients, but as individuals, with rights, preferences, and expertise, who are able to rely on a system which supports them and only intervenes proportionately
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act (web accessible), page 6
The government has invested over £400 million to eliminate dormitory provision in mental health facilities.
We are investing over £400 million to rid the mental health estate of dormitory provision, just as the Review recommended.
Financial · Funding statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act (web accessible), page 6
The annual salary of a full-time equivalent IMHA is estimated at £25,000 in 2019/20 prices.
The annual salary of a FTE IMHA is estimated as £25,000 in 2019/20 prices using feedback from service providers.
Financial · Funding statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: impact assessment, page 65
The number of people entitled to Independent Mental Health Advocate (IMHA) support is expected to increase by 20% in the first year after implementation, falling to a 1% increase annually thereafter.
This proposal increases the eligible population by 20% in 2023/24 falling to a 1% increase on the BAU in later years to account for a stable number of inpatients in recent years. That is, when detentions increase, the number of voluntary patients decrease as we are assuming a stable number of inpatients (voluntary and detentions).
Policy · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: impact assessment, page 64
The business as usual (BAU) option assumes an annual rate of increase of 1.2% for the number of CTOs based on historical data from 2010/11 to 2015/16.
CTO BAU forecast assumes an annual rate of increase of 1.2% based on the average rate of increase over the past seven years data from 2010/11 to 2015/16 (excluding the MHSDS dataset)
Operational · Procedural statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: impact assessment, page 60
The number of Community Treatment Orders (CTOs) is expected to decrease by around 40% within five years after the implementation of the Independent Review recommendations.
If all the Review recommendations are implemented, then the Review expected that CTOs would decrease by half 5 years after implementation. In the absence of evidence supporting this assumption and considering that the detention criteria are not being reviewed at this point, which would affect the potential number of CTOS, we assume that, after 5 years of gradual implementation of the Review’s recommendations, CTOs will decrease by around 40% (instead of the 50% expected reduction).
Policy · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: impact assessment, page 60
The NHS Long Term Plan aims to stabilize and bolster current core community services from 2019/20, with a goal of 100% coverage of 24/7 age-appropriate crisis care by 2023/24.
• From 2019/20, local services are expected to “stabilise and bolster current core community services” (p.26). • By 2023/24, there will be 100% coverage of 24/7 age-appropriate crisis care, including (p.30):
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: impact assessment, page 56
The annual growth rate of detentions is estimated to be 6%, starting from the year 2016/17.
• The weighted average of the growth over the last six years produces a yearly growth rate of 6%. We have assumed that the data quality of KP90 is at 100%, that is, giving equal weighting to all KP90 growth rates and placing much less emphasis on the MHSDS growth figures. The annual growth rate of 6% is applied from the year 2016/17.
Metric · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: impact assessment, page 55
The baseline number of detentions in 2015/16, adjusted for double counting, is approximately 54,000.
• The baseline is calculated as the 2015/16 KP90 count adjusted for double counting, by using the percent of transfers on section in 2016/17’80: 63,622 detentions * (100%-15%) ≈ 54,000.
Metric · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: impact assessment, page 55
The NHS Long Term Plan is expected to reduce detentions by 10% over five years, leading to a decrease in secondary care costs.
We then assume in our central scenario that this trajectory will decrease by 10%, from improvements in mental health community care services and crisis services delivered through the LTP.
Service · Trend statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: impact assessment, page 51
Option 2 is the preferred option as it aligns with policy objectives and improves patient choice, dignity, and therapeutic environments.
Overall, Option 2 is considered to be the preferred option as the implementation of the Independent Review’s recommendations is expected to help achieve the policy objectives and make the MHA more fit for purpose.
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: impact assessment, page 50
The estimated cost for the private sector due to changes in the MHA is below £5 million per year.
To estimate the costs for private funding and independent sector supply, we applied the 2.9% market share to the overall estimated cost in each year and that provides an estimate of around £1.1m per year over the period – this is below £5m in each year (see table 31 below).
Financial · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: impact assessment, page 49
The number of Community Treatment Orders (CTOs) is expected to grow by 1.2% annually, but could range from a 6% decrease to a 9% increase.
In the central scenario, the number of CTOs is assumed is to grow 1.2% each year of the forecast based on historical trends (average from 2010/11 to 2015/16). This a volatile time series with an increase in one year followed by a decrease in the following year in general
Operational · Procedural statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: impact assessment, page 44
The number of detentions is expected to increase by 6% annually without policy changes, but could range from a 2% decrease to a 10% increase.
In the central scenario we assume that detentions would increase 6% per year in the absence of any policy changes. This assumption is based on historical data that are not directly comparable as the official data source for MHA changed in 2016/17
Operational · Procedural statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: impact assessment, page 44
The costs of the policy could range from £0.9 billion to £4.4 billion depending on various assumptions.
if all the assumptions made throughout the IA were to be the worst cases, then the NPV of the costs of Option 2 could rise to £4.4 billion; on the other hand, if the assumptions took on their best cases, costs could fall to £0.9 billion
Financial · Risk statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: impact assessment, page 48
The policy is expected to reduce the number of repeat detentions and improve patient safeguards, potentially leading to cost savings.
Similarly, improved patient safeguards and involvement in decision making could also lead to improved treatment adherence and, in turn, a reduction in the number of people with repeated detentions. Currently, 15.5% of people are detained more than once in a year – under 6,500 people in 2018/1954.
Operational · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: impact assessment, page 42
Healthier individuals contribute more to the economy through increased workforce participation, reduced absence, and higher productivity.
There is evidence that healthier people contribute substantially more to the economy, acting through a variety of channels such as: greater investment in human capital due to expectations of a longer working life38, greater labour market participation with increased retirement age and reduced absence from work39, greater productivity and wages40, 41, and greater savings rates42 (also giving rise to greater capital investment).
Financial · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: impact assessment, page 39
The proposed policy Option 2 is expected to improve mental health outcomes and contribute significantly to economic benefits.
Under the proposed policy Option 2, it is also expected that there will be significant economic and social gains resulting from the improvements in health and wellbeing of patients detained under the MHA, largely through the improvements in human capital but also through wider impacts on the economy.
Financial · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: impact assessment, page 39