Evidence browser
Explore the evidence
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
36,013 claims
The government will not proceed with reforming the interface between the Mental Health Act and the Mental Capacity Act at this time.
In light of the feedback received, we do not intend to take forward reform of the interface, as set out in the White Paper, at this time.
Policy · Commitment statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 67
The government will launch a pilot programme for culturally appropriate advocacy to address disparities in care for black groups.
We have committed to launch a pilot programme of culturally appropriate advocacy to identify how advocacy can respond appropriately to the particular needs of individuals, especially from black groups where we know there are significant disparities in care and treatment under the Act.
Policy · Commitment statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 62
Respondents agreed that consistent quality and accessibility to IMHAs would be improved by enhanced standards, regulation, and accreditation.
Overall, 85% of responses agreed/strongly agreed with the proposal; while 2% disagreed/strongly disagreed and 12% were not sure.
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 61
Respondents agreed that Independent Mental Health Advocates (IMHAs) should have additional powers to support patients in challenging detention and appealing treatment decisions.
There were 1,302 responses to this question. Overall, 85% of responses agreed/strongly agreed with the proposal; while 5% disagreed/strongly disagreed and 9% were not sure.
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 60
The majority of respondents agreed with the proposal to give patients the right to choose a Nominated Person (NP) who can represent them.
There were 1,302 responses to this question. Overall, 78% of responses agreed/strongly agreed with the proposal; while 7% disagreed/strongly disagreed and 15% were not sure.
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 56
The majority of respondents agreed that advance consent to informal admission should be set out in the Mental Health Act and its Code of Practice, but raised concerns about implementation and patient safeguards.
There were 1,242 responses to this question. Overall, 64% of responses agreed/strongly agreed with the proposal; while 17% disagreed/strongly disagreed and 19% were not sure.
Policy · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 52
Respondents expressed concerns that the proposal to allow patients to challenge treatment decisions at the Mental Health Tribunal could undermine clinical decision-making if judges lack necessary expertise.
A large proportion of the respondents who disagreed with the proposal cited concerns around a member of the judiciary influencing clinical decision making. Some felt that it was wholly inappropriate as the Tribunal judge is unlikely to have the clinical expertise necessary to make such a decision, potentially putting the patient at risk.
Policy · Risk statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 50
The majority of respondents agreed that patients with capacity should have the right to refuse urgent treatment considered necessary to alleviate serious suffering.
There were 1,294 responses to this question. Overall, 56% of responses agreed/strongly agreed with the proposal; while 25% disagreed/strongly disagreed and 19% were not sure.
Policy · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 46
The government plans to continue working with stakeholders to develop the proposal for Advance Choice Documents, ensuring children can benefit from them.
We will continue to work closely with stakeholders to establish how we can align advance choice decision making under the MHA with the MCA. We value the feedback we have received from stakeholders with regard to the complexities associated with children. We will continue to develop our proposal to ensure that children benefit from using Advance Choice Documents as a tool to inform their care and treatment.
Commissioning · Commitment statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 41
Respondents expressed concerns about practical barriers and potential risks associated with the implementation of Advance Choice Documents.
Of the minority of people who disagreed with the approach, many were worried that the Advance Choice Document could too easily be dismissed by the clinician and ignored.
Operational · Risk statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 39
The majority of respondents agreed with the proposal to align advance decision making under the Mental Health Act with the Mental Capacity Act.
Overall, the majority of respondents agreed with the proposed approach.
Policy · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 39
The Government is committed to introducing Advance Choice Documents as a means for patients to set out their care and treatment preferences in advance.
We are committed to introducing Advance Choice Documents as a means of providing people with the opportunity to set out in advance the care and treatment they would prefer, the name of their chosen nominated person, and any treatments they wish to refuse, in the event they are detained under the Act and lack the relevant capacity.
Policy · Commitment statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 35
Respondents were divided over the proposal to remove associate hospital managers’ panels in discharging patients from detention.
There were 1,270 responses to this question. Overall, 42% of responses agreed/strongly agreed with the proposal; while 23% disagreed/strongly disagreed and 35% were not sure.
Policy · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 33
The majority of respondents expressed concerns about the feasibility of implementing directions within a five-week timeframe.
Additionally, a large number of respondents thought the timeframe to deliver on directions should be flexible, judged on a case by case basis with an option for extensions.
Operational · Risk statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 31
The government intends to remove automatic referrals to the Tribunal following a revocation of a Community Treatment Order (CTO).
We proposed to remove the automatic referral to a Tribunal received by service users when their community treatment order is revoked.
Policy · Commitment statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 27
The government acknowledges concerns about the impact of more frequent automatic referrals on Tribunal resources and patient experience.
Many respondents were supportive of the proposals but were concerned about the increased resource that more frequent automatic referrals would require and how that could negatively impact the quality of justice being delivered to Tribunal users.
Governance · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 25
The government plans to increase automatic referrals to Tribunals for patients under Section 3 from six months to four months.
For patients subject to Section 3, there was general agreement with the proposal of referral at 4 months rather than 6.
Policy · Commitment statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 25
The government proposes to increase the frequency of automatic referrals to the Mental Health Tribunal for patients under different sections.
We proposed that: For patients subject to a Section 3, referral would instead take place 4 months after the detention started, if the Tribunal has not considered the case in the first 4 months. Thereafter, referral would take place 12 months after the detention started, if the Tribunal has not considered the case in the intervening months.
Policy · Procedural statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 23
The majority of respondents support changing detention criteria to require therapeutic benefit and substantial likelihood of significant harm.
There were 1355 responses to this question. Overall, 82% of responses agreed/strongly agreed with the proposal; while 8% disagreed/strongly disagreed and 10% were not sure.
Policy · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 19
The government will continue to work on embedding guiding principles in everyday practice.
We will continue to work to take forward the principles. We will seek to incorporate the feedback received from the consultation as we consider the how the principles are embedded in everyday practice and application of the Act.
Operational · Commitment statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (web accessible), page 18