Evidence browser
Explore the evidence
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
36,013 claims
The total additional estimated costs for implementing the Government proposals on the Mental Health Tribunal are £164 million over ten years.
Total additional estimated costs cover automatic referrals (see Annex D), treatment choices, and legal aid impact, as shown below in more detail. They were estimated using a forecast of the number of receipts/hearings multiplied by the average sitting day costs for a MHT (see Annex C for further detail).
Financial · Funding statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 17
The Quality Improvement Programme will cost around £2 million overall.
It is estimated that the QI programme will cost around £2 million overall, including a robust co-design phase, followed by national implementation and evaluation – see table 10 below.
Financial · Funding statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 16
The proposed MHA reforms will result in an additional cost of £378 million over ten years for clinical teams, including support for mental health tribunals and ACDs.
The total additional costs over the appraisal period is estimated at £378 million.
Financial · Funding statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 15
The implementation of the proposed MHA reforms will result in an additional cost of £147 million over ten years for Independent Mental Health Advocates.
Table 2 illustrates the spend for a central scenario over the ten year period from 2023/24 to 2032/33, showing an overall estimated additional cost of £147 million.
Financial · Funding statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 12
The Business As Usual (BAU) option assumes no changes to the Mental Health Act and considers only current national policies in England.
The Business As Usual option (BAU) assumes that there are no changes to the MHA and that none of the Government proposals are implemented. This is the counterfactual used in this IA, which reflects the status quo considering only current national policies in England.
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 6
The government plans to amend detention criteria so that it is only used when there is a clear therapeutic benefit and substantial likelihood of significant harm.
The Government proposed to amend the detention criteria of section 3 of the MHA and elsewhere so that detention for treatment is only undertaken when it is clear that this will be therapeutically beneficial for the individual. The Government is also proposing to amend the detention criteria for sections 2 and 3 of the Act, and elsewhere, so that, for someone to be detained, it must be demonstrated that there is a substantial likelihood of significant harm to the health, safety or welfare of the person, or the safety of any other person.
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 6
The government proposes to introduce Advance Choice Documents (ACDs) for patients to set out their care and treatment preferences in advance.
The Government proposed to introduce Advance Choice Documents as a means of providing people with the opportunity to set out in advance the care and treatment they would prefer, and any treatments they wish to refuse, in the event they are detained under the Act and lack the relevant capacity to express their views at the time.
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 6
The reforms aim to reduce racial disparities and promote equality under the Mental Health Act.
reduce racial disparities under the MHA and promote equality
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 1
The government aims to modernize mental health legislation to improve care quality and promote recovery.
To modernise mental health legislation and ensure care and treatment is of the highest quality and promotes recovery;
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 1
The government intends to proceed with a duty on adequacy of supply for mental health services.
Based on strong support we intend to proceed with the proposal on adequacy of supply.
Policy · Commitment statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (print ready), page 102
The government proposes to create a new duty on local commissioners to ensure adequacy of supply of community services for people with learning disabilities and autistic individuals.
In order to ensure the right services are available in the community, for people with a learning disability and autistic people to prevent unnecessary admission into hospitals and to speed up discharges, the White Paper proposes to create a new duty on local commissioners
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (print ready), page 96
The majority of respondents agreed that recommendations from Care, Education, and Treatment Reviews (C(E)TRs) for children and Care Treatment Reviews (CTRs) for adults should be formally incorporated into care and treatment plans.
Overall, 62% of responses agreed/strongly agreed with the proposal;
Policy · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (print ready), page 93
The government will explore further the issue of differential thresholds for discharge under Part II of the Mental Health Act.
We will therefore commit to exploring this issue further, including through an expert group.
Policy · Commitment statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (print ready), page 92
The majority of respondents support the proposal to limit detention under Section 3 of the Mental Health Act for people with learning disabilities and autism.
Overall, 62% of responses agreed/strongly agreed with the proposal; while 16% disagreed/strongly disagreed and 22% were not sure.
Policy · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (print ready), page 81
The government aims to redefine the role of social supervisors and provide clearer national guidance on their responsibilities.
The Government wishes to strengthen and further develop the role of social supervisor and has consulted with stakeholders on how best to achieve this.
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (print ready), page 79
The government plans to grant the Tribunal and Justice Secretary power to issue supervised discharges for restricted patients.
We will move forward with our plans to provide the Tribunal and the Justice Secretary with the power to grant a supervised discharge to restricted patients
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (print ready), page 78
The government proposes to introduce a new power of supervised discharge for restricted patients who no longer benefit from hospital treatment but continue to pose a risk.
We propose that individuals would only be eligible to be discharged in this way if it posed the least restrictive option for them.
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (print ready), page 75
The government plans to introduce a 28-day time limit for transferring individuals from prison or IRC to mental health inpatient settings.
We will take forward legislative change to introduce the 28-day time limit. However, this will only be commenced once the NHSEI guidance on transfer and remissions has been fully embedded
Operational · Commitment statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (print ready), page 74
The government will introduce an independent role within NHS England or across NHS England and HMPPS to manage secure transfers from prison or IRC.
We will continue work to introduce the independent role, utilising feedback received through the consultation when deciding where the role should sit.
Operational · Commitment statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (print ready), page 71
The government will give health professionals in A&E the power to hold individuals pending a clinical assessment.
We will seek to give powers in legislation to health professionals in accident and emergency departments so that individuals in need of urgent mental health care stay on site, pending a clinical assessment...
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response (print ready), page 69