Evidence browser
Explore the evidence
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
36,013 claims
The cost of a SOAD visit is estimated at £403 in 2020/21 prices.
The CQC have provided a high level breakdown of the cost of running the SOADs provision for 2018/19. These have been averaged over all 14,354 visits in 2018/19 to calculate a unit cost per visit £403.
Financial · Metric statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 70
The model estimates that moving SOAD provision from 3 months to 14 days for refusals and from 3 months to 2 months for those lacking capacity will increase the number of SOAD visits.
It also shows that an additional 50% of Section 3 detainees would become eligible if SOADs were triggered from 3 months to 15 days for refusals. It also shows that an additional 11% of Section 3 detainees would become eligible if SOADs were triggered from 2 months rather than 3 months for those lacking capacity.
Operational · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 69
The number of mental health inpatients is assumed to remain constant at the 2016/17 level of around 103,000.
Data from NHSD indicate that the number of mental health inpatients over recent years has been fairly consistent. We therefore assume that the number of mental inpatients remains fixed at 2016/17 levels of around 103,000.
Service · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 64
The uptake of IMHA services is estimated to be around 40% based on academic studies and provider feedback.
A rounded average uptake of 40% was derived from these two studies and this estimate was supported in discussions with providers of IMHA services.
Service · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 63
The number of CTOs is expected to decrease by 40% over five years starting in 2023/24.
We assume that the start date of the policy is 2023/24 once legislative changes are in place and that it goes through a five-year gradual implementation period. Staff contact time (RCs and care co-ordinators) for current responsibilities was assumed to remain the same post-policy implementation.
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 61
The average cost of a length of stay for detentions under the Mental Health Act is estimated at around £23,300.
The cost was then inflated to 2020/21 prices using a GDP deflator. The cost of length of stay in 2020/21 prices is estimated at around £23,300
Financial · Metric statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 57
The reduction in detentions due to improved mental health crisis and community-based services is expected to start in 2023/24, with a phased decrease over five years.
In line with the Review’s expectations, we assume that these improvements could lead to a reduction in detentions of around 10%. This reduction is assumed to start in 2023/24
Policy · Commitment statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 56
The introduction of Advance Choice Documents (ACDs) is expected to reduce detentions by more than 1,200 annually.
The introduction of ACDs under Option 2 is estimated to lead to a reduction in the number of detentions by more than 1,200 every year and around 21,000 detentions in total over the 10-year appraisal period
Policy · Commitment statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 56
The number of detentions under the MHA is expected to increase by 2.05% annually in the absence of policy improvements.
Detentions under the MHA would increase by 2.05% per year (based the adjusted average estimates from NHSD) if no policy improvements took place.
Operational · Procedural statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 51
The estimated net benefit over a 12-year period is -£1,450 million in 2020/21 prices.
Over the 12 year time horizon, the estimated net benefit are estimated to be -£1,450 million in 2020/21 prices and in Present Value terms. This pertains to monetised benefits estimated at £340 million minus costs (including health opportunity costs) estimated at £1,790 million.
Financial · Funding statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 49
Option 2 is expected to bring significant benefits to patients by increasing patient choice and autonomy, ensuring dignity and respect, improving therapeutic environments, and promoting equality.
Overall, Option 2 is considered to be the preferred option as the implementation of the Government proposals is expected to help achieve the policy objectives and make the MHA more fit for purpose. The proposals are expected to bring significant benefits to patients interacting with the MHA through increasing patient choice and autonomy over their treatment, ensuring they are treated with dignity and respect, improving inpatient therapeutic environments and promoting equality throughout the process.
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 49
The estimated additional costs for the private sector are below £5 million per year, which is unlikely to impose a substantial burden.
To estimate the costs for private funding and independent sector supply, we applied the 2.9% market share to the overall estimated cost in each year and that provides an estimate of around £1 million per year over the period – this is below £5 million in each year
Financial · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 48
The total additional cost to the Justice system could range between around £80 million and £210 million over the time horizon.
The total additional cost to the Justice system could range between around £80 million and £210 million in constant prices over the time horizon.
Financial · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 46
The costs of clinical teams could increase or decrease by around £230 million based on a 13% change in hours.
The first key impact to highlight is the clinical teams’ increase in hours following the implementation of the recommendations, as flexing these times by 13% could increase or decrease costs by around £230 million.
Financial · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 45
The monetised benefits of the proposed policy option are estimated at £337 million over a ten-year period, ranging from £95 million to £525 million.
The benefits associated with the proposed policy option are likely to be significant. However, due to the absence of quantitative evidence for these impacts, as explained above, we were only able to monetise some impacts from ACDs and from tribunal cancellation fees in the Justice system – see table below. They are estimated at £337 million over the appraisal period in a central scenario (ranging from £95 million to £525 million).
Financial · Funding statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 39
Advance Capacity Directives (ACDs) are more cost-effective and provide a greater sense of autonomy for black service users compared to other ethnic backgrounds.
Studies from the United States and United Kingdom have shown that ACDs may be most effective among service users of black ethnicity compared to those of other ethnic backgrounds. ACDs resulted in black service users being more likely to have an increased sense of autonomy66 and being the more cost-effective option67 compared to other ethnic backgrounds.
Service · Observational claim · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 39
The Government is introducing an Organisational Competency Framework to improve patient access and experience for black and minority ethnic people.
The Government is introducing a new Organisational Competency Framework, which will support NHS mental healthcare providers work with their local communities to improve the ways in which patients access and experience treatment.
Policy · Policy statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 38
The government is committed to working with organisations involved in the Mental Health Act system to improve data quality and digitisation, aiming for a fully digitised approach by 2024.
The UK Government proposes that NHS England should build on the work of the Mental Health Trust Global Digital Exemplars and other trusts to test, evaluate and roll-out a fully digitised, consistent approach to the MHA. Digital transformation is at the heart of the NHS LTP. Through the wider transformation portfolio, including the Global Digital Exemplar and Local Health and Care Record programmes, all mental health providers are expected to progress, by 2024, to a core level of digitisation.
Operational · Commitment statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 23
The government has committed to launching a pilot programme for culturally-sensitive advocates in partnership with local authorities and others, starting preliminary research on cultural appropriate advocacy in 2021/22.
The Government has committed to launching a pilot programme of culturally-senstive advocates in partnership with local authorities and others, to identify how best to represent the mental health needs of ethnic minority backgrounds and it has allocated some initial funding to conduct preliminary research on cultural appropriate advocacy in 2021/22.
Commissioning · Commitment statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 22
The government has allocated £3 million for research projects on reducing detention rates and improving experiences of people from minority ethnic backgrounds under the Mental Health Act.
This funding in the value of £3 million pertains to 2020/21 – as these costs were incurred in the past, they are not included in this IA in line with Government guidance
Research · Funding statement · From Reforming the Mental Health Act — Reforming the Mental Health Act: government response to consultation: impact assessment, page 22