Evidence browser
Explore the evidence
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
36,013 claims
The voice of the young person should be heard, and advocacy roles strengthened.
There is evidence that advocacy arrangements for CYP, particularly those who are looked after, should be strengthened to ensure that their voices are heard through the pathway. Access to advocates should be considered on an opt out basis.
Operational · Policy statement · From Serious incident investigation report excerpt: Secretary of State case review into Beth — Serious incident investigation report: Secretary of State case review into Beth, page 11
Robust escalation processes should include a system navigator to coordinate cases of significant concern.
There is evidence that when an individual’s care pathway becomes complex across partner agencies that lack of joined up working will have an impact on the outcomes. The worker must have the autonomy and authority to work across all partner agencies and instruct change.
Operational · Policy statement · From Serious incident investigation report excerpt: Secretary of State case review into Beth — Serious incident investigation report: Secretary of State case review into Beth, page 11
Hospital environments should be adapted for children and young people with autism.
There is evidence to show that children with autism are admitted to mental health units as a last resort and that the environments do not meet their needs. No children with autism should be admitted to a mental health hospital in the absence of a mental health need and therefore with a clear therapeutic intent and expected outcomes.
Operational · Policy statement · From Serious incident investigation report excerpt: Secretary of State case review into Beth — Serious incident investigation report: Secretary of State case review into Beth, page 11
Parents should be involved as partners in decisions about their children's care and management.
There are reports from parents of an absence of meaningful involvement in decisions relating to the care and management of their children. Development of a parental rights-based approach is needed to ensure that wherever possible no decision about their child without their involvement or the involvement of the young person is made.
Operational · Policy statement · From Serious incident investigation report excerpt: Secretary of State case review into Beth — Serious incident investigation report: Secretary of State case review into Beth, page 10
Strategic planning is needed to stimulate market provision for community care of young people with autism.
There is evidence that children and young people with autism are being admitted to inappropriate placements due to a lack of appropriate community provision. A joint programme of work with families, Department for Education, Department for Health and Social Care, NHSE, Association of Directors of Children’s Services, and providers is needed to ensure provision at scale that will deliver robust and reliable care close to home.
Operational · Policy statement · From Serious incident investigation report excerpt: Secretary of State case review into Beth — Serious incident investigation report: Secretary of State case review into Beth, page 10
A mandatory requirement for the assessment of human rights should be introduced when restrictive interventions are used.
There is evidence that formal assessments of the implications of the human rights act in relation to the care and management of children and young people with autism are not undertaken. An organisation with expertise in human rights in the context of health and social care should be commissioned to assist in developing the framework and provide training for all registered professionals and commissioning staff.
Operational · Policy statement · From Serious incident investigation report excerpt: Secretary of State case review into Beth — Serious incident investigation report: Secretary of State case review into Beth, page 10
A national review of the workforce and training plan is needed to establish new roles and competencies.
There is evidence that the workforce supporting children and people with autism are often inadequately trained, supported and supervised. Therefore this plan is to ensure the delivery of developmental, physical, psychological and educational goals with a view to establishing a skilled workforce;
Operational · Policy statement · From Serious incident investigation report excerpt: Secretary of State case review into Beth — Serious incident investigation report: Secretary of State case review into Beth, page 10
Seclusion or segregation should be used only as a last resort and subject to stringent review.
There is evidence that admission to inappropriate physical environments initiates a cycle of behaviour that challenges, resulting in increasingly restrictive practices including seclusion. In turn children can learn to equate seclusion with safety, thus, limiting their ability to reintegrate.
Operational · Policy statement · From Serious incident investigation report excerpt: Secretary of State case review into Beth — Serious incident investigation report: Secretary of State case review into Beth, page 9
Personalised crisis response plans should be co-designed with young people and parents, owned by all stakeholders.
Where there is potential for crisis, children and young people should be identified on the regional dynamic support register. There is evidence that when the support of a child is in crisis a containment response is initiated by the responsible authority which may then lead to placement breakdown and seeking of a further form of containment through the police and /or hospital.
Operational · Policy statement · From Serious incident investigation report excerpt: Secretary of State case review into Beth — Serious incident investigation report: Secretary of State case review into Beth, page 9
Early integrated working across health, social care, and education is required with a statutory requirement for joint planning.
Numerous reports have identified that early intervention is required to prevent the pathway to institutionalised care. Lenehan (2017) identified the model of care that would be required. This is dependent upon joint planning across health, education and social care and experience indicates that this needs to be a statutory requirement for these agencies rather than the existing good practice guidance.
Operational · Policy statement · From Serious incident investigation report excerpt: Secretary of State case review into Beth — Serious incident investigation report: Secretary of State case review into Beth, page 9
The report aims to balance Bethany's privacy with transparency in the mental health system.
At this time, we are disclosing those elements of the final report which we are confident strike the right balance between protecting Bethany’s privacy and promoting transparency in our mental health system.
Governance · Procedural statement · From Serious incident investigation report excerpt: Secretary of State case review into Beth, [page]
The review was conducted by NHS England to understand the circumstances and prevent future incidents.
It has looked the circumstances that led to the care of Bethany at St Andrews Healthcare and the role played by relevant statutory organisations across the system and over time. The review was intended to identify learning that could help prevent such events happening again.
Governance · Procedural statement · From Serious incident investigation report excerpt: Secretary of State case review into Beth, [page]
The Secretary of State for Health and Social Care requested a review under the Serious Incident Framework.
This review was requested by the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care under the Serious Incident Framework into the care of Bethany
Governance · Procedural statement · From Serious incident investigation report excerpt: Secretary of State case review into Beth, [page]
The prolonged use of seclusion for Bethany is considered a significant failure in care.
Such a prolonged use of seclusion is considered a significant failure of care and warrants full investigation.
Service · Observational claim · From Serious incident investigation report excerpt: Secretary of State case review into Beth, [page]
Bethany was a Looked After Child who spent nearly two years in seclusion at St Andrews Healthcare.
Bethany was a Looked After Child (LAC) who was reported to have been regularly detained in seclusion for close to 2 years while an inpatient at a child and adolescent mental health service provided by St Andrews Healthcare,
Service · Observational claim · From Serious incident investigation report excerpt: Secretary of State case review into Beth, [page]
Effective prevention strategies can protect children from risk factors that contribute to problematic behaviors, gang affiliation, and poor mental health.
Effective prevention strategies can protect children from the risk factors that contribute to problematic behaviours, gang-affiliation and poor mental health
Policy · Policy statement · From Mental health: needs of gang-affiliated young people — The mental health needs of gang-affiliated young people, page 31
Young people involved in gangs often face multiple health and social problems, necessitating holistic support.
Such holistic support is likely to be particularly important for young people involved in gangs who often face multiple health and social problems
Service · Observational claim · From Mental health: needs of gang-affiliated young people — The mental health needs of gang-affiliated young people, page 29
Comprehensive CAMHS provide a framework for collaborative work to support the mental health needs of gang-affiliated young people.
Comprehensive CAMHS are important partners in work to support the emotional and mental health needs of gang-affiliated young people
Service · Policy statement · From Mental health: needs of gang-affiliated young people — The mental health needs of gang-affiliated young people, page 29
School-based programmes aimed at promoting mental wellbeing and addressing poor mental health have been shown to be effective.
There is growing evidence for school-based programmes that aim specifically to promote mental wellbeing and address poor mental health.
Service · Observational claim · From Mental health: needs of gang-affiliated young people — The mental health needs of gang-affiliated young people, page 28
Schools play a key role in supporting the mental health needs of vulnerable children and young people, including those at risk of or affiliated to gangs.
Schools have a key role to play in supporting the mental health needs of vulnerable children and young people, including those at risk of, or affiliated to gangs.
Policy · Policy statement · From Mental health: needs of gang-affiliated young people — The mental health needs of gang-affiliated young people, page 28