Evidence browser
Explore the evidence
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
36,013 claims
Further consideration is needed for appropriate outcome measures and quantifying benefits of universal prevention and promotion.
On the whole, further consideration of appropriate outcome measures for universal prevention and promotion, and better approaches for quantifying the potential benefits, is needed.
Metric · Commitment statement · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 12
There is a need to better quantify the economic benefits of universal wellbeing-focused interventions.
The lack of evidence around the cost effectiveness of interventions meeting our criteria was disappointing. This absence may be partially due to the inclusion of systematic reviews rather than individual studies and the challenges of quantifying the economic benefits of universal wellbeing-focused interventions when applied to the whole population as described above (Arango et al., 2018).
Financial · Commitment statement · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 11
Complex interventions aimed at systemic change are recommended for further consideration.
Therefore, consideration of methods and approaches that account for systemic change and aim to investigate complex interventions are recommended (Rutter et al., 2017).
Research · Procedural statement · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 11
There is a need to consider outcomes at family, school, and community levels.
The poor representation of interventions aiming at levels other than the individual level suggests a pressing need to consider outcomes in terms of family level, such as improving the quality of parent–child relationships; school level, such as a focus on the context of the learning environment; and community level, such as a focus on wider determinants (for example housing, poverty) and/or those engendering a sense of social connectedness, belonging, control and/or voice.
Service · Policy statement · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 11
Further research is needed to address the limitations in evaluating universal interventions.
However, it is also possible that there is limited effectiveness of universal interventions, and this should be explored further. In the absence of a clear evidence-base pointing to effective practice, it is important that those implementing interventions carry out their own evaluation and monitoring in situ to establish whether the support put in place is achieving the desired outcome.
Research · Commitment statement · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 11
There is a need for common measures to assess mental health interventions.
It would be very helpful for the field if a core set of common measures were used. Attempts have been made to collate and clarify relevant measures of mental health, wellbeing and resilience
Metric · Policy statement · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 10
The review identified a wide range of interventions but only a few can be described as promising.
While the review identified a wide range of interventions, there were a limited number which can be described as ‘promising’. Those that were promising were supported by mixed evidence of effectiveness.
Service · Observational claim · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 10
No systematic reviews were found that addressed the cost-effectiveness of universal interventions.
Cost effectiveness: No systematic reviews were identified that addressed cost effectiveness or value for money of universal interventions to promote resilience or wellbeing or prevent mental ill health.
Financial · Observational claim · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 9
Most interventions focus on preventing mental health problems rather than promoting wellbeing.
The majority of individual studies focussed on considering impact in terms of prevention of mental health problems and promotion of resilience as opposed to promotion of wellbeing.
Service · Observational claim · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 9
There is a lack of evidence for interventions operating at the family, school, and community levels.
The vast majority of individual studies identified related to interventions operating at the individual level with far fewer interventions found at the family level and school level, and none identified which focused at the community level (except in the grey literature).
Service · Observational claim · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 9
The majority of interventions identified in the review operate at an individual level.
As with the synthesis of systematic reviews, on the whole there were more interventions operating at the individual level (n = 50) than at the school (n = 11) or family level (n = 11), but there were also some interventions identified that operated at the community level (n = 4).
Service · Observational claim · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 9
Typical characteristics of promising interventions aimed at children and young people include being provided in schools, offered in group settings, and led by professionals.
Of those 6 promising individual interventions aimed at children and young people, typical characteristics include: 1. provided in schools; 2. offered in group setting (often a class);
Research · Observational claim · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 8
Eight interventions were identified as promising, with four showing evidence of long-term effects.
Eight interventions met the criteria for being categorised as promising: 6 of these interventions were focussed on the individual (child) level
Research · Observational claim · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 8
None of the interventions showed clear evidence of a sustained, meaningful effect to improve mental health and wellbeing.
Overall there was no clear evidence of an evaluated universal intervention that consistently shows a sustained, meaningful effect to improve mental health and wellbeing
Research · Observational claim · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 7
The most commonly reported outcome was preventing emotional difficulties, followed by improving resilience and then preventing behavioural difficulties.
The most commonly reported outcome was preventing emotional difficulties, followed by improving resilience and then preventing behavioural difficulties
Research · Observational claim · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 7
Eight interventions were identified as promising based on having at least two studies reporting positive outcomes.
Of these interventions, 8 had shown some evidence of promise based on having at least 2 studies reporting positive outcomes
Research · Observational claim · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 6
The review also considered interventions aimed at promoting wellbeing of children and young people.
What approaches have shown evidence of being effective in promoting wellbeing of children and young people (considering resilience and subjective wellbeing)?
Research · Policy statement · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 5
The review considered interventions aimed at preventing mental health problems in children and young people.
What approaches have shown evidence of preventing mental health problems in children and young people (considering behavioural and emotional difficulties)?
Research · Policy statement · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 5
The review aimed to identify, synthesise and present key evidence of universal approaches to improving mental health and wellbeing of children and young people.
To identify, synthesise and present key evidence of universal approaches to improving mental health and wellbeing of children and young people
Research · Policy statement · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 4
There is an increasing focus on finding the best approaches to support prevention of mental health problems and promotion of positive mental health at the earliest possible stage.
In light of this there is increasing focus on seeking to find the best approaches to support the prevention of mental health problems and promotion of positive mental health at the earliest possible stage
Policy · Policy statement · From Children and young people’s mental health: prevention evidence — Lay summary report of the synthesis of systematic reviews and grey literature review , page 4