Evidence browser
Explore the evidence
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
35,999 claims
Some carers were treated with disrespect and rudely when visiting patients.
“…my family told me that when they came to visit or had something to ask they were sometimes greeted with a moody response...”
Relational · Observational claim · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 39
Carers often felt their views were not listened to or taken seriously by clinical teams.
A significant theme in the accounts of carers (and those with lived experience) is that carers’ views were often not listened to or taken seriously. In the region of 75 carers (10%+) described feeling ignored by the clinical team.
Relational · Observational claim · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 39
There is a perception that tribunals are less fair than criminal court cases.
...there were more rights and safeguards in a criminal court case than in a tribunal...
Policy · Observational claim · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 31
Carers feel their voices are not heard at tribunals.
...We were not informed until close to the date of her tribunal - which came as a huge shock and was a cause for massive anxiety for us...
Policy · Observational claim
There is concern that people are being discharged just before their tribunals.
...I have also often seen consultants discharging patients the day before the tribunal as they knew they would be released...
Policy · Observational claim · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 31
Some respondents want to be able to choose their own 'nearest relative' under the Act.
...The person or people who have regular contact with and provide support should be consulted in a section tribunal, not a relative who may have a poor or non-existent relationship with the patient...
Policy · Observational claim · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 30
There is a desire for more regular tribunals and free legal advice on tribunals.
A desire for more regular tribunals and free legal advice on tribunals featured in the responses.
Policy · Observational claim · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 30
Some respondents felt that the tribunal process is biased against patients.
There were a few had experienced a tribunal where they felt they had been treated very unfairly.
Policy · Observational claim · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 30
There was a call for more culturally responsive mental health services, particularly for BAME communities.
...the right to services responsive to BAME communities if requested as part of the aftercare plan...
Service · Policy statement · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 26
Community Treatment Orders (CTOs) were criticized for focusing too much on medication and not addressing broader recovery issues.
...On a Community Treatment Order care is unhelpful and inadequate. It does not allow me to recover as I am forced to continue taking medications, which make me physically and emotionally unwell...
Service · Observational claim · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 24
The quality of care was often perceived as poor, with a focus on medication rather than holistic recovery approaches.
There were a great many comments on the quality of care (there are of course a variety of ways of expressing this, for example, around 50 people (6%+) with lived experience and 60 carers (8%+) described the care they experienced as ‘poor’) and just how limited the treatment offer could be...
Service · Observational claim · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 24
Peer support workers were seen as valuable in providing better mental health care both in hospitals and the community.
Those with lived experience saw a role for peer support workers (over 40 or 5% mentioned peer support workers in their accounts) and for increasing their numbers, seeing them as having a role in better mental health care both in hospital and the community...
Service · Policy statement · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 23
Respondents highlighted the need for holistic care, including support with housing and finances.
It is important that there is an actual life waiting for you when you leave hospital. Often the situation you were in before detention is drastically different when you leave. For example, you may have lost your job, lost contact with friends and family, you may have lost your home etc. The hospital needs to make sure you do not completely sever all ties with your life in the community...
Service · Observational claim · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 22
Respondents noted that continuity of care and consistent mental health team support were important for preventing readmission.
Comments were made about failings in providing continuity when a person was transferred from one ward or hospital to another, and even more so when leaving hospital and returning to the community
Service · Observational claim · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 20
Respondents emphasized the importance of better resourced and more reactive mental health services in the community.
This theme overlaps with those above and others but goes beyond a desire for better crisis responses. It encompasses a desire to see better resourced and more reactive mental health services in the community
Service · Reform statement · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 19
Respondents highlighted missed opportunities for earlier intervention that could have prevented the need for use of the Mental Health Act.
Whilst not strictly speaking a ‘reform theme’, the many missed opportunities described can illustrate the changes required. Several examples were given of how some earlier intervention might have prevented the need for use of the Mental Health Act
Policy · Observational claim · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 18
Some respondents reported poor experiences with home treatment services, while others had positive accounts.
Specific references to home treatment services were made by 33 (4%) people with lived experience and 26 (4%) carers. Some people reported a very poor experience of home treatment: ... There were positive accounts of home treatment, and presumably these were better planned and resourced than the first account above
Service · Observational claim · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 17
Respondents suggested that early intervention and better crisis response could prevent the need for use of the Mental Health Act.
Early intervention, prevention, and a better crisis response
Policy · Reform statement · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 16
Some respondents, particularly those with lived experience and carers, did not want any changes to the Mental Health Act.
There were also those, both carers (in the region of 60 or 8%+) and those with lived experience (19 or 2%) who stated a clear ‘nothing’ when asked what they would change about the Act, that wanted to see no change and thought the Act was as it should be.
Policy · Stakeholder position · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 14
Over a quarter of carers had experience of Section 3 and just under 10% of people with lived experience reported having been detained under this section.
Over a quarter of carers had experience of Section 3 and just under 10% of people with lived experience reported having been detained under this section.
Service · Observational claim · From Modernising the Mental Health Act – final report from the independent review — Mental Health Act survey: key themes, page 12