Evidence browser
Explore the evidence
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
35,999 claims
The average quality adjusted life year (QALY) gain of CYPMHS services for anxiety or depression is estimated at around 0.1.
We estimate the average benefit of CYPMHS treatment for anxiety or depression as around a 0.1 (10%) increase in quality of life.
Metric · Metric statement · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 30
The sensitivity analysis shows that varying assumptions can result in a range from £2907m to £7879m for the benefits of Options 3 and 4.
PV benefits, low case (£) Present value benefits, high case (£) Adjustment to average benefit:cost ratio to account for uncertainty in interventions chosen 3939m 7879m Number of CYP receiving targeted intervention in school 2024m 6242m % who would have got the same benefit in CAMHS 3742m 3939m
Metric · Metric statement · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 27
The total quantified benefit of Option 4 is equal to the total quantified benefit of Option 3.
Given the uncertainty around the number of weeks that average waiting times will reduce by we have not been able to quantify the expected benefits. Therefore, the total quantified benefit of Option 4 is equal to the total quantified benefit of Option 3.
Metric · Metric statement · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 26
The total present value cost of Option 4 is £1,309 million.
Total present value cost: £1,309m
Financial · Funding statement · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 25
The cost of the CYPMHS waiting times pilots will be around £50 million between 2018/19 to 2020/21.
We expect the CYPMHS waiting times pilots will be supported by funding and an evaluation. For the purpose of this analysis, we assign a total cost of c. £50m between 2018/19 to 2020/21.
Financial · Funding statement · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 25
The estimated benefits for each child participating in an intervention include NHS savings of £2,100 and productivity gains of £1,600.
NHS saving (£) 2,100 Productivity (£) 1,600
Financial · Funding statement · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 22
The illustrative benefits of delivering interventions by Mental Health Support Teams are based on evidence from established specialist programmes.
We have used evidence of cost-effectiveness of established specialist programmes.
Service · Policy statement · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 20
The Mental Health Support Teams are expected to deliver targeted interventions that either have evidence of being cost-effective or are innovative with emerging evidence.
We would expect support teams to deliver targeted interventions in schools that either i) have evidence of being cost-effective, or ii) are innovative interventions with emerging evidence about effectiveness or cost-effectiveness.
Service · Policy statement · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 20
The total quantified benefits of Option 3 are estimated at £3,939 million.
Total present value benefit: £3939m
Financial · Funding statement · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 23
The total quantified costs of Option 3 are estimated at £1,265 million.
Total present value cost: £1,265m
Financial · Funding statement · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 19
The Mental Health Support Teams will provide focused evidence-based interventions with appropriate clinical supervision.
new Mental Health Support Teams are proposed which will comprise trained staff offering focused evidence -based interventions, with appropriate clinical supervision .
Service · Policy statement · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 14
The total present value cost of Mental Health Support Teams over ten years is estimated at £1,223 million.
Total present value cost: £1,223m
Financial · Funding statement · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 18
The total annual financial cost of employing staff within the Mental Health Support Teams is estimated at £360 million.
It is estimated that nationally approximately 8,000 FTE would be employed within the Mental Health Support Teams at an annual financial cost of £360m (at full roll out).
Financial · Funding statement · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 18
The total cost of Option 2 is estimated at £83 million in present value.
Total present value cost: £83m
Financial · Funding statement · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 16
The cost of rolling out the schools-CYPMHS link training is estimated at £7.6 million over five years.
The cost of the roll out of the schools -CYPMHS link training is estimated to be around £7.6m, likely to be spread over five years.
Financial · Funding statement · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 16
Emerging evidence suggests that the prevalence of mental health problems among children and young people may have increased since 2004, particularly among young women.
Emerging evidence provides a mixed picture on trends in prevalence of mental health problems but overall suggests that proportions of CYP with mental health issues may have increased since 2004 , especially among young women and girls.
Context · Trend statement · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 13
The policy objective is to improve quality of life and outcomes for children and young people with mental health conditions, reduce the severity and impact of these conditions, and decrease burdens on healthcare and criminal justice systems.
To increase support to children and young people (CYP) with mild to moderate m ental health conditions in England, and to reduce the length of time that those who need specialist NHS Children and Young People’s (CYP) mental health services wait for treatment. The intended effects are: To improve quality of life for CYP living with a mental health condition; To improve outcomes for CYP living with a mental health condition; To reduce the severity and impact of mental health conditions and thereby: o improve future earnings/productivity; o reduce burden on the health and social care system; o reduce burden on the criminal justice system.
Policy · Policy statement · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 12
School-based mental health support is valued by children and young people, who consider school-based counselling helpful.
CYP themselves value school- based mental health support and consider school-based counselling helpful.
Service · Stakeholder position · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 11
Half of adults with diagnosable mental health problems had symptoms before age 15, and seventy-five percent by age 18.
Longitudinal research from New Zealand shows that half of 26 year old adults with a diagnosable mental health problem also had symptoms before age 15, and seventy-five per cent before age 18.
Context · Observational claim · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 10
Early intervention is cost-effective compared to later-stage interventions.
There is evidence that intervention in childhood is more cost-effective than intervention at a later stage.
Policy · Observational claim · From Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: a green paper — Impact assessment on the children and young people's mental health green paper, page 8