Evidence browser
Explore the evidence
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
35,999 claims
The NHS Workforce Race Equality Standard is being considered for application to mental health policies.
At an organisational level, our attention has been drawn to emerging successes of the NHS Workforce Race Equality standard in tackling inequalities in the NHS workforce, and we will consider how such approaches could be translated to mental health policies.
Policy · Policy statement · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 40
The use of restrictive practices varies widely between Mental Health Trusts and disproportionately affects certain groups, including BAME individuals.
There are also specific issues for service users with non-traditional family structures, families, carers and friends who live a long way from the hospital and those who have suffered physical, sexual and psychological abuse at the hands of family members
Service · Observational claim · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 34
There are concerns about the overrepresentation of BAME individuals, particularly black African and Caribbean men, in CTOs.
'Black or Black British' people are nine times more likely to be given a CTO than white people
Service · Observational claim · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 35
The nearest relative provision in the MHA is no longer considered fit for purpose.
Our view is that this no longer fit for purpose
Policy · Policy statement · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 32
People from BAME backgrounds and older people face specific challenges in accessing IMHA services.
There is also evidence that indicates people from BAME communities and older people have specific and greater problems accessing IMHAs
Service · Observational claim · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 32
Advocacy services do not adequately address the multiple disadvantages faced by BAME communities.
advocacy provision does not address the multiple disadvantages and discriminations faced by BAME communities
Service · Observational claim · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 32
The review will consider whether service users have enough say in MHA decisions and how this could be increased.
We are not yet minded to recommend moving immediately to ‘fuse’ mental health legislation and mental capacity legislation, not least because this is would take many years to design. However, this is an option to be considered seriously for future reform.
Service · Commitment statement · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 28
The review will consider whether NHS England should take over the commissioning of health services in police custody.
We believe that the care of people in cells is as much an issue for health and social care as it is for police. We will consider whether NHS England should take over the commissioning of police custody health care services, or otherwise create a plan so that people in police custody get better care, and faster transfers out to NHS and social care services.
Commissioning · Commitment statement · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 26
Service users often do not feel safe, treated with dignity or that their human rights are respected while detained under the MHA.
It is concerning that people often do not feel safe, treated with dignity or that their human rights are respected whilst detained.
Service · Observational claim · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 26
There is a concern that people arrested under criminal law stay in police cells for too long after an AMHP has decided they should be admitted to hospital.
Another emerging issue is that people who are arrested under criminal law stay in police cells for too long after an approved mental health professional (AMHP) has decided that they should be admitted to hospital.
Operational · Observational claim · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 25
The police's role in mental health care includes immediate responses and sectioning people under sections 135 and 136 of the MHA.
The use of these powers has remained at a high level over the last decade. This underlines the importance of the police role, but also challenges the NHS to ensure that services are available and ready to take over responsibility at the most appropriate time.
Operational · Observational claim · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 24
The review is considering whether sections 2 and 3 of the MHA should be combined or reconfigured.
whether sections 2 and 3 of the MHA should be combined or reconfigured, with an initial shorter period for assessment and treatment
Policy · Commitment statement · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 22
There are concerns about the decision-making process at the point of detention under the MHA.
there are concerns about the decision-making process at the point of detention and the ability for service users to challenge these decisions
Service · Stakeholder position · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 22
Detention rates under the MHA in England are rising faster than elsewhere in Europe.
detentions rates in England5 are about average for Europe, but they appear to be rising faster in England than elsewhere
Metric · Observational claim · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 20
The review has commissioned academic literature reviews on various themes related to the MHA.
We have commissioned academic literature reviews to gather the latest evidence on the following themes:
Research · Procedural statement · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 17
The review received over 2,000 survey responses from people affected by the MHA.
Received over 2,000 survey responses
Service · Observational claim · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 17
The review will explore opportunities for reform in detail to make the Mental Health Act work better.
During the course of the review we will explore many opportunities for reform in detail. We have developed a set of more detailed goals to help guide our work.
Policy · Policy statement · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 10
The review will examine issues of racial disparities in detention under the Mental Health Act.
Our terms of reference ask us to make recommendations for improvement in relation to rising detention rates, racial disparities in detention, and concerns that the act is out of step with a modern mental health system.
Policy · Policy statement · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 10
The review aims to improve dignity and respect for service users under the Mental Health Act.
It is clear that the MHA needs to change. The need to tackle this lack of dignity and respect drives many of the specific reform areas that we are considering.
Policy · Policy statement · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 11
The review will consider the interaction between the Mental Health Act and the criminal justice system.
We want to rescue the notion of the ‘informal patient’ who is not subject to legislation. As well as tackling rising detention rates, we intend to consider what should, and should not, amount to a ‘deprivation of liberty’ at the interface of the MHA and the Mental Capacity Act.
Policy · Policy statement · From Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report — Independent review of the Mental Health Act: interim report, page 12