Evidence browser
Explore the evidence
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
35,999 claims
Debt advice services can improve mental health and reduce GP consultations for patients with debt-related stress.
Better management of debt can also have an impact on the use of health services. In a small scale study in Sefton a significant reduction in the number of GP appointments and use of anti-anxiety medications, along with non-significant reductions in the use of antidepressants and nurse time was observed in patients who had been referred to a CAB advice service (Krska et al., 2013).
Service · Observational claim · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 94
Signposting services can reduce loneliness and improve mental health, potentially saving money on GP consultations.
The intervention modelled here focuses on the provision of a signposting service for people aged 65 and older who are not in paid work to help identify opportunities for participation in a wide range of local social activities. Such signposting services have been put in place in different areas of England; they vary in the way they operate with some located in GP surgeries, others in local focal points such as shopping centres or libraries, and others that proactively seek to identify and engage with potentially isolated individuals.
Commissioning · Policy statement · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 92
Engaging in social activities can help protect mental wellbeing and reduce the risk of depression among older people.
A recent systematic review to inform NICE guidance looked at non-health sector delivered interventions to promote the mental wellbeing and independence of older people (McDaid et al., 2015b). It found that a wide variety of actions to improve access to social contacts and networks and participation in social activities, including various arts and cultural activities, initiatives to sign post individuals to social activities and friendship building programmes could all help protect mental wellbeing.
Service · Observational claim · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 90
Collaborative care in primary care settings is cost-effective for addressing depression in individuals with diabetes or coronary heart disease.
There is consistent evidence from the US that the approach in primary care settings is cost-effective in addressing depression in individuals with diabetes or coronary heart disease (Johnson et al., 2016, Katon et al., 2012, Molosankwe et al., 2012, Hay et al., 2012); furthermore, better management of depression can help reduce the costs of managing the physical health condition.
Service · Observational claim · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 88
A universal social and emotional resilience programme can reduce new cases of depression in children.
There is evidence on the impacts of universal mental health promotion programmes in workplaces. A recent systematic review and meta-analysis for preventing depression in workers using CBT-based programmes showed significant positive results (Tan et al., 2014).
Service · Observational claim · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 87
The Penn Resilience Programme, adapted and delivered in England by trained school staff, has shown positive short-term impacts on child depression, emotional wellbeing, and academic performance.
Delivered by trained school staff, the programme was also found to have positive short-term (less than one year) impacts on child depression, emotional, behavioural, social, and school wellbeing. There were also impacts on school performance and level of school absenteeism.
Service · Policy statement · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 85
The KiVa programme, which has shown effectiveness in Finland and is being piloted in England and Wales, aims to reduce bullying through enhancing empathy and self-efficacy among peers.
KiVa focuses on enhancing the empathy, self-efficacy, and anti-bullying attitudes of classroom peers; positive changes in the behaviour of pupils who are neither bullies nor victims can reduce the rewards that bullies perceive that they receive and thus reduce the incentives for bullying.
Service · Policy statement · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 82
Children who have been bullied are at increased risk of depression, anxiety disorders, suicidality, poor social relationships, economic hardship, and lower quality of life in adulthood.
Individuals bullied in childhood had increased levels of psychological distress at ages 23 and 50. Victims of frequent bullying also had higher rates of depression (OR 1.95), anxiety disorders (OR 1.65) and suicidality (OR 2.21) compared with children who had not been bullied.
Context · Observational claim · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 81
Commissioners should incorporate evaluation and routine monitoring into pilot projects to allow for comparison of results from small-scale studies.
National and local commissioners of pilot projects should consider how best to build evaluation and routine monitoring of outcomes into these projects. In doing so, consideration should be given to making more consistent use of established robust outcome measures
Commissioning · Procedural statement · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 61
There is a need to better capture the economic consequences of poor mental health, including impacts on productivity and unpaid care.
In particular, research needs to be better at capturing the wide range of economic consequences of poor mental health, both across all relevant service systems and in terms of effects on productivity, family support and other unpaid care
Research · Policy statement · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 61
Future research should evaluate the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of interventions to promote mental health, considering impacts on various sectors beyond healthcare.
Evaluations of the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of interventions to promote mental health and wellbeing and the prevention of mental health problems. Interventions should evaluate impact on key outcomes of interest to all relevant sectors that would commission and/or deliver these interventions.
Research · Policy statement · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 61
The new model for suicide and self-harm prevention complements the findings of the 2011 report by focusing on secondary prevention.
This report models a complementary intervention to that assessed in the 2011 model. This model looks at the potential benefits of increasing the use of psychosocial assessments (in line with NICE guidance) for individuals who subsequently present at accident and emergency departments following a deliberate non-fatal self-harm event.
Research · Comparative statement · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 60
The suicide prevention programme saves an additional 2,733 years of life over a ten-year period compared to usual support.
Over the ten years, 2,733 years of life would be saved with the suicide prevention intervention and 2,693 with usual support
Service · Observational claim · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 46
The conservative assessment of savings from the suicide prevention programme includes £1.43 million per 100,000 population over a ten-year period.
When the costs to the police (investigations), local authorities (coroners) and society are included these savings increase to £1.43 million per 100,000 population
Financial · Observational claim · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 45
The suicide prevention programme yields a return on investment (ROI) of £39.11 for every pound invested.
the model estimates that there is a ROI of £39.11 for every pound invested in suicide prevention
Financial · Observational claim · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 45
Increasing the use of psychosocial assessment for individuals presenting at hospital with deliberate self-harm can result in a ROI of £39.11 per pound invested over ten years.
Overall, at the end of the 10 year time period the model estimates that there is a ROI of £39.11 for every pound invested in suicide prevention; 40 years of additional life are gained by the intervention cohort.
Financial · Observational claim · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 45
Face-to-face debt advice services can save up to £1.43 million in costs per 100,000 population over ten years when considering broader economic impacts.
There are also broader economic benefits associated with debt advice services that have not been included, which in some analyses mean the ROI is greater than £6 for every £1 invested (Clifford et al., 2014). Another analysis looking at impacts on creditors and issues such as homelessness has suggested a ROI of more than £50 per £1 (Farr et al., 2014).
Financial · Observational claim · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 39
Face-to-face debt advice services yield a return on investment (ROI) of at least £2.60 for every £1 invested over five years.
Over five years from a societal perspective there is a ROI of at least £2.60 from every £1 invested investing in face-to-face debt advice services.
Financial · Observational claim · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 39
Collaborative care for individuals with diabetes and/or coronary heart disease can achieve a return of £1.52 for every pound invested over two years.
Over two years from a societal perspective there is a ROI of at least £1.52 from investing in this service
Commissioning · Observational claim · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 30
A workplace cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) service can generate a positive return of £2 for every pound invested by the end of Year 2.
the programme generates a positive ROI overall by the end of Year 2, from the perspective of the employer, with the ROI greater (£2 for every £1 invested) if impacts on health services are taken into account
Commissioning · Observational claim · From Mental health services: cost-effective commissioning — Commissioning cost-effective services for promotion of mental health and wellbeing and prevention of mental Ill-health, page 28