Evidence browser
Explore the evidence
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
35,999 claims
The pilot programme significantly improved the sharing of mental health resources and information between different organisations.
Among respondents to the 4 combined surveys at the +10 months stage (n =215), 47% agreed and 13% strongly agreed that the pilot programme had brought about improvements to the sharing of mental health resources and information between different organisations within their local area.
Service · Observational claim · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 87
The pilot programme led to a reduction in inappropriate referrals and improved referral quality.
While these outcomes are more difficult to quantify, it is notable that well over half of respondents to the 4 combined surveys (59%) agreed or strongly agreed that the pilot programme had brought about improvements to the effectiveness of referral routes that are available to specialist mental health support for children and young people within the local area.
Service · Observational claim · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 82
The satisfaction with referral handling by NHS CYPMHS increased significantly.
This increase was highly significant, at the 1% level.
Service · Observational claim · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 80
The pilot programme improved understanding of referral routes to specialist mental health support.
Across all 4 surveys, well over three-quarters of respondents (78%) agreed or strongly agreed that the pilots had improved their understanding of the referral routes to specialist mental health support for children and young people in their local area.
Policy · Observational claim · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 80
The availability of mental health support within pilot schools increased, particularly in therapeutic support and staff training.
The types of provision showing the greatest increase in availability in pilot schools included: therapeutic support/interventions, staff training and whole school strategies. By the end of the programme, the most widely offered provision included staff training, educational psychological support and learning in the curriculum.
Service · Observational claim · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 71
The pilot programme improved understanding of referral routes to specialist mental health support for children and young people among school lead contacts.
Across all surveys, well over three-quarters of all respondents agreed or strongly agreed that the pilots had improved their understanding of the referral routes to specialist mental health support for children and young people in their local area.
Service · Observational claim · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 71
The proportion of school lead contacts who found it easy or very easy to arrange a consultation with specialist NHS CYPMHS increased significantly.
Overall, there was a sizeable increase in the proportion of school lead contacts who felt that it was either ‘easy’ or ‘very easy’ to arrange a consultation with specialist NHS CYPMHS when they needed one, rising from just under one-half of respondents at baseline, to just over three-quarters of respondents by the follow-up stage.
Service · Observational claim · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 71
The pilot improved knowledge and awareness of mental health issues among school staff.
Eight in 10 of all respondents (80%) either agreed or strongly agreed that the pilots had improved their knowledge and awareness of mental health issues affecting children and young people.
Service · Observational claim · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 70
Direct communication between schools and NHS CYPMHS was a key feature of the pilot.
While the individual contact between NHS CYPMHS and schools was a key feature of the pilot, a number of sites also made use of multi-agency panels or forums to share information multi-laterally.
Operational · Procedural statement · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 65
Training on outcome measures improved data quality in some areas.
While not all areas provided training to schools on using common outcome measures, there were a number of examples where this was managed successfully, resulting in improvements to data quality.
Service · Observational claim · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 64
The second approach involves dedicated training and support time for school-based professionals without significant direct work with young people.
b) NHS CYPMHS named lead offering dedicated training and support time to school-based professionals
Service · Procedural statement · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 57
The third approach offers a single point of access to NHS CYPMHS via telephone or email, focusing on improving communication and clarity.
c) NHS CYPMHS named lead or duty team with designated responsibilities for the pilot, offering single point of access
Service · Procedural statement · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 58
The first approach involves direct support from NHS CYPMHS to staff and young people with regular contact time.
a) NHS CYPMHS lead with contact time in schools on a regular basis, delivering services and support directly to staff and young people
Service · Procedural statement · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 56
There was variation in the staffing model adopted by schools and NHS CYPMHS for the pilot.
The number of FTE PMHW ranged from 1 to 7. This usually reflected the numbers of schools to be covered, as some pilots subsequently recruited additional schools and were working with 20 or more. It often also reflected the level of staffing that was needed to offer a ‘guarantee’ of a fixed number of hours of contact time per week with individual schools.
Operational · Observational claim · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 53
The CASCADE framework was sometimes seen as mismatched with the workshop audience and too time-consuming.
This was viewed as a useful tool to support strategic planning by some, and the small group discussions around the 7 criteria highlighted some important issues that were carried forward into the resulting action plan. The framework was sometimes felt to have been mismatched with the workshop audience, however, with participants not always feeling sufficiently well informed to contribute, and some commented that the scoring exercise was too time-consuming and detracted from opportunities for stakeholder engagement.
Operational · Observational claim · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 49
Joint planning workshops helped schools understand the NHS CYPMHS service structure.
Schools had often previously overestimated the size of the service, but seeing the CCG presentation and hearing from the NHS CYPMHS manager highlighted the difficult staffing ratios.
Service · Observational claim · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 48
The demand for face-to-face contact time from NHS CYPMHS lead contacts varied between individual schools, with secondary schools often requiring higher levels of support than primary schools.
The demand for face-to-face contact time from NHS CYPMHS lead contacts varied between individual schools. Secondary schools often perceived a need for higher levels of contact time than primaries, although this was not always the case.
Operational · Observational claim · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 44
The joint planning workshops were generally well-received and helped to establish new contacts between schools, NHS CYPMHS, and other CYPMH services.
Participants generally welcomed the combination of factual information, benchmarking and action planning. A few areas commissioned further workshops from the AFNCCF consortium, to extend the opportunity to additional schools.
Operational · Observational claim · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 42
The initial development of the pilot programme was delayed by up to six months due to difficulties in finding suitable link workers and organising resource requirements.
This inevitably resulted in delays with assigning link worker(s) to schools, while suitable arrangements were agreed to backfill or put in place interim posts. This was estimated to take anything up to 6 months in some instances
Operational · Observational claim · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 41
The pilot programme received a high level of interest, with over 90 applications from CCGs and local demand often exceeding available places.
There was a high level of response, with over 90 applications from CCGs. This response was mirrored locally in many areas, where the demand from local schools often outstripped the number of available places.
Commissioning · Observational claim · From Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation — Mental health services and schools link pilot: evaluation, page 37