Evidence browser
Explore the evidence
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
35,999 claims
Responses generally agreed that people should receive care planning and discharge planning from the time of hospital admission, but there were mixed views on whether this should be a statutory requirement.
Overall, 187 responses answered this question. Responses generally agreed that people should receive care planning and discharge planning from the time when they are admitted, but there were mixed views about whether this should be a statutory responsibility.
Policy · Observational claim · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 62
There was widespread support for strengthening individuals' rights to request a transfer to less restrictive settings or closer to home.
Overall, 191 responses considered this question. There was widespread support for this proposal.
Policy · Observational claim · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 57
About half of respondents agreed that an approval mechanism for inpatient admissions should be given statutory force.
There were mixed views. About half of the responses agreed that an approval mechanism should be given statutory force (47%).
Policy · Observational claim · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 55
Six out of ten respondents agreed that a gateway or approval mechanism for admissions to inpatient settings may be useful.
There were 147 responses that answered this question. The feedback was very mixed. Six out of ten responses agreed that a gateway or approval approach may be useful, two out of ten did not and the rest provided other broad comments
Policy · Observational claim · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 51
Three-quarters of respondents agreed that health and social care should seek documented consent before admitting someone to an inpatient setting.
There were 205 responses that answered this question. The feedback was mixed. Three quarters of responses agreed that health and social care should have to seek documented consent before making an admission (76%).
Policy · Observational claim · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 49
There is support for changing information required by Mental Health Act regulations to promote greater accountability.
I strongly support this idea. Clarity needs to be given on appropriate responses and not just 'there are no community services that are suitable' but rather specifics are needed. This should also be discussed with the service user/family.
Policy · Policy statement · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 43
Proposals for community-based mental health services may require significant investment but could result in long-term savings.
Costs will depend on how the support is provided and costs will need to be revised with ongoing new developments in treatment and management. Community services with the right support may not be less expensive than hospital care initially, but in the long run may reduce direct and indirect costs.
Financial · Funding statement · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 41
Local commissioners should be held accountable through audits and reviews of health and social care outcomes.
A clarity at a national level as to specifications of models and services that would need to be in place would, alongside rigorous data on local population needs, make it possible to ensure local commissioners were held to account through audit of services provided and reviews of health and social care outcomes.
Governance · Procedural statement · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 40
Responses recommend setting up robust data collection and monitoring systems to ensure effective implementation of community inclusion duties.
the importance of clear responsibility and accountability (6 responses) require effective data collection and monitoring systems to be set up, including needs analysis, mapping of current provision and accountability for implementation. This may involve oversight by regulators
Operational · Procedural statement · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 39
Responses suggest that local authorities and clinical commissioning groups should consider providing sufficient community-based support and treatment services.
Most responses agreed that local authorities and the NHS should have to consider how to provide enough community-based support and treatment services (90%).
Commissioning · Policy statement · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 36
Responses indicate that financial pressure is a significant negative impact on local authorities and the NHS when considering factors supporting community inclusion.
The potential impacts mentioned by responses focused on processes, culture, service provision and finances. Cost is obviously an impact.
Financial · Risk statement · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 34
Responses indicated that joint working between the NHS and local authorities is essential for addressing complex needs.
if budgets and commissioning are joint between the NHS and local authorities, legal responsibilities and accountability should also be the same. Joint commissioning and budgets may have many benefits
Operational · Stakeholder position · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 29
90% of respondents agreed that local authorities and NHS commissioners should consider factors supporting community inclusion when determining living arrangements.
A total of 389 responses addressed these questions. Most responses were favourable about local authorities and NHS commissioners having to think about factors that would help people stay close to home and maintain links with family and friends (90%).
Policy · Observational claim · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 30
94% of respondents agreed that NHS commissioners should have the same duty as local authorities under the Care Act to prioritize individuals' wellbeing.
In total, 211 responses provided feedback about this question. Most responses agreed that NHS commissioners should have the same duty as local authorities under the Care Act to put people’s wellbeing at the heart of what they do (94%).
Policy · Observational claim · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 27
Most respondents suggested that clearer responsibilities and enhanced service provision are needed for the physical healthcare of people in mental health inpatient settings.
Other comments focused on clearer responsibilities and enhancing service provision
Service · Stakeholder position · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 18
Consultation respondents agree that the Mental Health Act Code of Practice should apply to clinical commissioning groups and NHS England commissioning.
260 97% 3%
Policy · Stakeholder position · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 15
Respondents support the idea of providing clear, easy-to-understand information about rights to individuals and their families by a named professional.
379 93% 2% 5%
Policy · Stakeholder position · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 10
Consultation respondents largely agree that local authorities and clinical commissioning groups should consider how to ensure there is enough community-based support for people with learning disabilities or autism.
214 90% 4% 6%
Policy · Stakeholder position · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 9
There is a high level of agreement (94%) that NHS commissioners should have the same duty as local authorities to prioritize individuals' wellbeing.
211 94% 2% 4%
Metric · Metric statement · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 8
Local authorities and NHS should consider factors that support community inclusion when determining living arrangements.
local authorities and the NHS should take into account factors that help people stay in their local communities
Policy · Policy statement · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 6