Evidence browser
Explore the evidence
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
35,999 claims
The guidance and the Serious Incident Framework together replace the 2005 Department of Health guidance on independent investigations.
The guidance, when read together with the serious incident framework, replaces the Department of Health guidance ‘Independent investigations of adverse events in mental health services’, published in 2005.
Policy · Policy statement · From ECHR Article 2: investigations into mental health incidents, [page]
The guidance provided in this document is intended for NHS organisations to meet Article 2 of the ECHR.
This document is for NHS organisations. It helps organisations meet Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) when making decisions about serious incidents in mental health services.
Policy · Policy statement · From ECHR Article 2: investigations into mental health incidents, [page]
NHS organisations should follow procedures outlined in the NHS England Serious Incident Framework to manage serious incidents.
The procedures to be followed when managing a serious incident are set out in the NHS England Serious Incident Framework – supporting learning to prevent recurrence.
Operational · Procedural statement · From ECHR Article 2: investigations into mental health incidents, [page]
Pooled funding for services can streamline care, reduce delays, and provide more holistic support.
Joint planning and pooled funding that follows the individual would allow for more creative ways of budget spending to prevent admissions and to speed up discharge processes. Experience shows that bureaucracy often delays and prevents personalised approaches to supporting individuals which is proven to be most effective.
Commissioning · Policy statement · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 108
There is general support for personal health budgets for everyone with learning disabilities or autism, but concerns about practical implementation and safeguards.
58% of responses said they supported personal health budgets for everyone
Policy · Stakeholder position · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 103
Respondents expressed concerns about the practical considerations and governance issues related to amending the Mental Health Act for restricted patients' discharge.
Responses that disagreed were concerned about the safety of individuals, the proportionality of restriction versus risks to self and others and practical difficulties implementing the law.
Policy · Stakeholder position · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 101
The majority of respondents believe that professionals other than police should be able to take people to a place of safety, but there are concerns about practical implementation.
There were mixed views. About two fifths of responses thought that professionals other than police should be able to take people to a place of safety (42%). The same proportion did not agree with this (45%).
Policy · Stakeholder position · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 97
Respondents widely supported limiting the use of police cells for those over 18 and reducing the duration of detention.
Overall, 164 responses answered this question. There was widespread support for this proposal.
Policy · Observational claim · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 93
There was widespread support among respondents to ensure that clinical commissioning groups and NHS England follow the Mental Health Act Code of Practice.
In total, 260 responses answered these questions. There was widespread support for this proposal.
Policy · Observational claim · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 91
Most respondents agreed that the Mental Health Act should be easier to understand, but many did not specifically agree with merging sections for assessment and treatment.
Around eight out of ten responses agreed with the proposal (79%) though many of these were agreeing that the Mental Health Act 1983 should be easier to understand, rather than agreeing about a single path for assessment and treatment.
Policy · Observational claim · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 89
Implementing a named social worker role may place a significant financial burden on local authorities.
We agree with this proposal provided that proper resources and funding are made available to support the implementation and effectiveness of such added responsibilities. We do not see any merit in adding to the burdens of social workers if at the same time measures are not taken to ensure that they are in fact able to fulfil the expectations.
Financial · Commitment statement · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 83
A named social worker could be a good idea but may not always prioritize service users' needs.
Disagree with this idea because social workers are working for local authorities and therefore acting on the council's behalf and not on behalf of the vulnerable person. They do not have the power to give information to people and their families/carers and do not have authority to make decisions.
Operational · Stakeholder position · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 82
Changing the law about nearest relatives may increase disputes due to capacity issues.
Responses that disagreed felt that either the change would have a negligible impact or that disputes may increase because biological ‘nearest relatives’ may make complaints if another person was chosen by a service user without proven capacity to make this choice.
Policy · Risk statement · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 81
Eighty-eight percent of respondents agreed that Independent Mental Health Advocates should be available to patients who lack capacity on an opt-out basis.
There was widespread support for this proposal, with nine out of ten responses thinking that this was a good idea (88%)
Service · Policy statement · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 76
Two-thirds of respondents agreed that only organisations including self and family advocates in their governance should receive contracts with local authorities or the NHS.
In total, 320 responses answered these questions. There were mixed views. Two thirds of responses supported this proposal (67%)
Commissioning · Policy statement · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 73
Responses support involving service users, carers, advocates, and a multidisciplinary team in decision-making processes for community treatment orders.
service user, carers, advocates and a multidisciplinary team should be involved in decision-making (28 responses)
Policy · Stakeholder position · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 72
A majority of respondents support the idea that people and their families should be able to challenge whether an Approved Mental Health Professional has properly taken into account their wishes and feelings.
About three quarters of responses thought that people and their families should be able to challenge decisions (76%).
Policy · Stakeholder position · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 68
Most respondents believe that more can be achieved through existing policies on delayed discharge, but there is a need for better implementation and resources.
We feel that the main issue in respect of existing policies and guidance relates to a lack of resources and a joined up approach by which to facilitate an individual’s discharge and care in the community.
Policy · Stakeholder position · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 67
A majority of respondents agree that care plans and discharge plans should be produced promptly after admission.
There was widespread agreement with this proposal.
Policy · Stakeholder position · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 64
There was widespread support for involving community-based professionals in discussions about care and treatment options.
Figure 16: Feedback from responses that answered Q16 Note: Percentages are based on 175 responses Agree 90% Disagree 3%
Policy · Observational claim · From Strengthening rights and choices for people to live in the community — Key themes from consultation responses, page 59