Evidence browser
Explore the evidence
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
35,999 claims
The quality of IPS services varied across sites with two being high fidelity and Centres of Excellence.
The quality of IPS services varied across sites. Two sites were pre-existing high fidelity services, and Centres of Excellence of IPS.
Service · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 47
The co-location of employment specialists with jobcentre staff was seen as beneficial for generating referrals.
Co-location of the employment specialist with the jobcentre staff is better so that we can actually get the referrals in and appropriate referrals.
Operational · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 39
Access to psychological therapy was a main reason for clients choosing to participate in the pilot.
Access to psychological therapy was one of the main reasons given by service users for their participation in the pilot. This was also reflected by JCP ESA Work Coach respondents, 70 per cent (n=30) of whom thought that a main reason that clients chose to participate in the pilot was to gain access to psychological therapy.
Service · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 41
The strict 'DNA' policy of IAPT services created barriers to accessing the pilot for some participants.
This was mainly focussed around the IAPTs strict ‘DNA’ (did not attend) policy wherein not attending two appointments or missing two attempts at contact without response resulted in the case being closed, thus meaning that the case should also be closed at the IPS service.
Operational · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 40
The referral process for the pilot was quick, with appointments with employment specialists within one to three weeks.
Service user participants... reported finding the referral process quick – having an appointment with the employment specialist within one to three weeks.
Operational · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 39
Inadequate communication and information provision to JCP ESA Work Coaches led to confusion about the pilot's processes.
...one Jobcentre...basically said all they got was a leaflet. A leaflet on the Friday that it rolled out the Monday...but the leaflet didn’t really explain anything. Employment Specialist
Operational · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 38
The eligibility criteria for the pilot were too restrictive, limiting the number of referrals.
Eligibility was very specific in early stages and I feel there would have been more referrals if more relaxed criteria. JCP ESA Work Coach
Operational · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 35
The lack of lead-in time and short duration of the pilot hindered its effectiveness.
Having more lead-in time to set up and promote the pilot was seen as improving the ability to promote the services, to develop good quality partnerships between services and to develop processes and communication channels which would ensure all stakeholders knew what was happening.
Operational · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 32
The pilot's short timeframe caused operational challenges in recruitment and staff training.
Recruitment of staff had to be swift which meant that some of the sites had to bypass their normal recruitment processes as they were too lengthy and they would not have had staff in post until half way through the pilot.
Operational · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 31
Service users valued the flexibility and person-centred approach of employment support provided outside Jobcentre Plus.
Flexibility was also frequently mentioned, particularly in terms of meeting times and locations, with the opportunity for them to be held in less formal locations (e.g. cafes) or even over the phone, depending on client preference
Operational · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 28
JCP ESA Work Coaches felt that the pilot was not well-coordinated and lacked sufficient information early on.
Engagement with JCP partners was however a weak point in many instances, particularly early on in the pilot. While 93 per cent of JCP ESA Work Coach respondents felt they understood the pilot, only three quarters felt they were given sufficient information
Operational · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 27
The partnership between IPS and IAPT services was facilitated by colocated teams and shared managers.
Some sites had IPS and IAPT services physically located together (co-located) with a shared manager. Others had to find different ways of working together, for example, placing IPS team members in IAPT services for short-periods
Operational · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 23
The delay in accessing IAPT services due to existing waiting lists hindered parallel support provision.
the opportunity for IAPT and IPS to demonstrate parallel working was somewhat limited. This was mainly due to the delays in service users receiving support from IAPT, due to pre-existing waiting lists
Operational · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 23
The pilot recommends extending the time frame to allow better setup and service embedding.
Increase time for the pilot, in terms of more time for: • Set-up: at least 6-8 weeks set-up time, to provide sufficient opportunity for recruitment and training of employment specialists; to market the service to potential users; to obtain buy-in from IAPT and JCP, and to develop appropriate referral routes and processes.
Commissioning · Policy statement · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 7
Data collection was challenging due to the involvement of two different services and lack of additional funding.
Difficulties in collecting the Management Information for this project were largely due to data being required from two different services, which were not necessarily co-located. There was no additional funding for data management
Operational · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 7
The pilot did not fully adhere to the IPS model due to insufficient setup time.
Not all IPS services were able to provide support which was fully reflective of the principles of IPS, given the lack of time for set up and for them to provide ongoing support to service users.
Operational · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 7
The pilot lacked sufficient time to deliver services effectively.
Engagement with and buy-in from IAPT and JCP was limited by the lack of lead-in time.
Operational · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 7
Fifteen service users achieved paid employment as a result of the pilot, with all successful outcomes occurring in sites A and D.
Fifteen service users achieved paid work as a result of the pilot – there were however 16 paid job outcomes, as one participant achieved two different paid outcomes at different times during the pilot period. All were in site A and site D.
Service · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 5
The main operational challenges included a lack of time to set up the pilot and engage partners, as well as delays in accessing IAPT services.
The main operational challenges centred on the lack of time provided to set-up the pilot – in terms of employing and preparing staff, embedding services, and establishing links and processes with partner bodies. Time taken for management of the pilot and for administration was also problematic.
Operational · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 4
The pilot intervention was characterised by extensive partnership working between IPS service providers, IAPT service providers, and Jobcentre Plus.
The pilot intervention was characterised by the extent of partnership working involved between the three parties: IPS service providers, IAPT service providers, and Jobcentre Plus.
Operational · Observational claim · From Helping people with mental health problems find work — An evaluation of the ‘IPS in IAPT’ psychological wellbeing and work feasibility pilot, page 4