Evidence browser
Explore the evidence
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
Loading the evidence…
Evidence browser
35,999 claims
The non-response rates and loss to follow-up introduce significant bias in the study's results.
The non-response at the end of the programme and at follow up are likely to introduce additional bias. It is likely that the people who stayed in the programme and those that completed the follow up questionnaires thought that they were benefiting.
Research · Observational claim · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, page 51
The report lacks a comparison group, making it impossible to conclude that the well-being programmes had any effect on participants.
Without randomisation there is the possibility that the intervention is being evaluated in a non-comparable group. Without a comparison group it is impossible to conclude that the intervention has had any effect on well-being.
Research · Observational claim · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, page 51
There is insufficient evidence to determine if well-being initiatives will have a public health benefit.
This report does not contain enough information about the methods used. The result is that there is insufficient quality of evidence to assess whether interventions aimed at improving health, mental health, social inclusion or physical activity (broadly, loosely and poorly defined in the report under a banner of ‘well-being’) will have any public health benefit.
Research · Observational claim · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, page 51
The NHS, Public Health England and Clinical Commissioning Groups should focus on investing in areas with a robust evidence base for mental health.
The NHS, Public Health England and Clinical Commissioning Groups should not commission services that ‘support mental well-being’, but should instead focus on investing where there is an evidence base. This falls clearly within the spheres of treatment and rehabilitation, mental illness prevention and mental health promotion.
Commissioning · Policy statement · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, Box 2.4
There is insufficient evidence to support a coordinated approach using universal or targeted well-being interventions in public mental health.
'Well-being interventions’ and services should not be funded in public mental health, but considered as one (poorly evidenced) strand within the WHO model of public mental health: mental health promotion, mental illness prevention, and treatment & rehabilitation. The promotion of mental well-being at a local level has insufficient evidence to support a co-ordinated priority approach using universal or targeted well-being interventions.
Commissioning · Policy statement · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, Box 2.4
Local authorities should not fund 'mental well-being' interventions into clinical care pathways.
We strongly discourage commissioning from ‘mental well-being’ into clinical care pathways.
Commissioning · Policy statement · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, page 46
There is a lack of consensus on the definition and measurement of well-being in mental health.
We currently have no consensus about what well-being actually is when considered in terms of mental health and mental ill health – let alone how to measure it and how we might develop, implement and evaluate interventions to improve it.
Metric · Observational claim · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, page 46
The quality of the well-being intervention literature is often poor and lacks scientific rigor.
Much of the commonly cited evidence base for well-being intervention evaluations as related to mental health is located within the grey literature, i.e. papers and reports which have not been subjected to independent peer review...
Research · Observational claim · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, page 44
Public funds should prioritize robust evidence-based areas of public mental health.
In challenging economic times, we contend that there is an even stronger imperative that public funds should be prioritised for investment in the many areas of public mental health for which we have robust evidence of effectiveness and cost-effectiveness.
Financial · Policy statement · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, page 45
The ONS's inclusion of 'anxious yesterday' as a measure of personal well-being may not be scientifically robust until the relationship between mental illness and mental well-being is better understood.
High subjective ‘anxious yesterday’ scores may apply to individuals from a variety of population groups with varying degrees of mental health and/or diagnosable mental illness. By simply including ‘anxious yesterday’ as a measure of personal well-being, the resulting ‘noise’ from true mental illness – which we should not assume is the polar opposite of ‘mental well-being’ – becomes impossible to distinguish in analysis of such data.
Metric · Observational claim · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, page 41
The evidence base for mental well-being is not yet robust enough to support the hypothesis that improving average levels of well-being would significantly reduce mental disorder.
Since that argument and mathematical model was articulated, evidence for interventions that ‘shift the curve’ in public mental health has simply not been forthcoming. In light of this, and the above, we question how appropriate it is to continue propagating the case for well-being – defined by both Huppert and the Foresight Report as primary prevention of mental disorder – using Rose’s approach in the absence of any empirical evidence.
Research · Observational claim · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, page 42
The current measures for mental well-being may inadvertently blur the boundaries between mental illness and mental well-being.
High subjective ‘anxious yesterday’ scores may apply to individuals from a variety of population groups with varying degrees of mental health and/or diagnosable mental illness. By simply including ‘anxious yesterday’ as a measure of personal well-being, the resulting ‘noise’ from true mental illness – which we should not assume is the polar opposite of ‘mental well-being’ – becomes impossible to distinguish in analysis of such data.
Metric · Observational claim · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, page 41
The ONS report shows a strong negative correlation between the Warwick Edinburgh Mental Well-being Scale (WEMWBS) and GHQ-12, indicating overlap but also distinctiveness.
analyses of survey data incorporating both of these measures have reported a strong negative correlation between WEMWBS and GHQ-12.43 In WEMWBS validation publications, GHQ-12 was moderately negatively correlated with WEMWBS
Service · Observational claim · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, page 39
The General Health Questionnaire (GHQ-12) is used as a screening measure for common mental disorders in the general population.
the GHQ items (when administered in 12, 28 or 30-item short forms) do not establish the presence of a clinical diagnosis, but provide evidence based logic for further evaluation by a healthcare professional trained in the evaluation of symptoms of psychiatric disorder.
Service · Procedural statement · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, page 39
The Office for National Statistics (ONS) developed a framework with 10 domains and 41 headline measures to assess national well-being.
the ONS has now developed and refined a framework assembling diverse indicators of well-being that might assist the ambition of national measurement, reporting and monitoring. This framework consists of 10 ‘domains’ and 41 ‘headline measures’,
Service · Policy statement · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, page 37
The WHO Mental Health Action Plan emphasizes the need for robust scientific evidence in mental health strategies.
It draws together the constituent components of public mental health and their metrics to allow progress to be monitored clearly and closely. The action plan clearly emphasises the need for robust scientific evidence to form the basis of mental health strategies for treatment, prevention and promotion
Policy · Policy statement · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, page 34
Effective prevention requires inter-sectoral linkages and a multi-pronged approach.
An effective prevention requires inter-sectoral linkages. An approach to prevention should include: needs assessment and programme development; dissemination and adoption; adaptation and tailoring; implementation; evaluation and monitoring; and sustainability
Policy · Policy statement · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, page 33
Policymakers should screen policy interventions to ensure they meet evidence-based requirements.
policymakers should make greater use of scientific knowledge before proceeding. For example, they should screen policy interventions to ensure that their effects meet a minimal set of evidence based requirements
Policy · Procedural statement · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, page 32
The Mental Health Intelligence Network should link routine mental health data with longitudinal survey data to better understand patterns of illness.
I recommend that the Mental Health Intelligence Network should link routine mental health data to longitudinal mental health survey data to better understand patterns of mental illness across the community, including those affected by the 75% treatment gap.
Metric · Commitment statement · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, page 19
Health and Wellbeing Boards should use Joint Strategic Needs Assessments to plan integrated mental and physical health services.
All Health and Wellbeing Boards should be informed by a Joint Strategic Needs Assessment (JSNA) which includes the information needed to plan services to integrate the mental and physical health needs of their populations.
Commissioning · Policy statement · From Chief Medical Officer annual report 2013: public mental health — Annual report of the Chief Medical Officer 2013, page 18